Ask the Yangxifu: My Chinese Boyfriend Doesn't Express His Feeings | Speaking of China

22 Responses

  1. Eileen黃愛玲
    Eileen黃愛玲 October 12, 2012 at 2:45 am | | Reply

    It’s the opposite with my relationship. I am the one who is subtile and my husband had the same concerns as you (he’s Taiwanese). I had a discussion with one of my Taiwanese friends and he said that his parents never even said, “I love you,” to him and such. I said, “They probably showed you that they loved you through their actions rather than words.” He nodded and said, “Exactly.” I am the same way. I never said “I love you” to my family. I don’t hug, either. =/ I tried to hug my dad once and it was so awkward. Fail. The thing is, we had extended family dinners all the time (not just Thanksgiving). My family stayed near each other and was always there when a family member was sick. My aunt quit her amazing job, moved back to a middle of nowhere, just for her mom.

    I am the same way with my relationships. For the longest time, my husband kept asking me, “How are you feeling?! What are you thinking?!” Now I attempt to talk about how I feel….but no promises.

    Side note: My husband was shocked when he found out my family take off the shoes before entering the home.

    “Still, I happen to think that talk about feelings is overrated. In the past, so many guys waxed poetically over how they loved this and that about me — and they all dropped me in the end. Meanwhile, I’m with the guy who still can’t put his feelings into some perfect Hallmark card. And he’s just perfect for me.”

    I couldn’t have said it better, myself.

  2. aiyangxifu
    aiyangxifu October 12, 2012 at 7:28 am | | Reply

    Classic introvert.

  3. aiyangxifu
    aiyangxifu October 12, 2012 at 7:30 am | | Reply

    And most Chinese believe “action speaks louder than words”

  4. askdsk
    askdsk October 12, 2012 at 7:43 am | | Reply

    If you grow up not able to put feelings into words, you lose that ability. People can learn to do more. It makes healthier relationship. I do not think many Chinese say thank you either through words. But they can use some more of those practices. Any intelligent women eventually will figure out who is saying stuff just to get into their pants.
    Women need those words more than men.

  5. Bruce
    Bruce October 12, 2012 at 9:45 am | | Reply

    We always say why he sounds so sweet but he is so lazy and such a sissy at the end. Some women love it when you’re so sweet and they don’t even care if it is true or it will come true or not. I guess that’s how you pick up women and then dump them at the end. NOW, my personality is both action and outspoken ( if I want to). I’m just too honest and I talk too much. Tell me if I need to shut up.

  6. Sveta
    Sveta October 12, 2012 at 11:51 am | | Reply

    The Korean man I’ve dated never expressed his feelings to me. No PDA, no gallant words, but I’m positive that he must have felt something for me back then because he was with me for two years, always wanted to know where I wanted to go and was very sweet respectful towards me. One time I wrote an interracial story of a Korean male/white female relationship and kind of included the possible emotions the guy wanted to express but never could to the girl and when he read it, he could really identify with it.

  7. Manny
    Manny October 12, 2012 at 12:22 pm | | Reply

    @Bruce, I cannot believe that Chinese men do not express love more openely! I did not know this fact. Now I know that they use subtle ways to express love. Now I am beginning to understand why no Chinese men paid any attention to my 2 pretty sisters even though they were dressed provacatively while walking down the streets in Hong Kong. My sisters and I had thought for sure they (my sisters) would receive some attention from the men but got none. Now things make sense to me!!!!! In order to woo a Chinese goddess, I must express my interest in them more subtly and more indirectly and be less aggressive. This weekend my sister Pam will come home from college and she said she will bring a female friend for a brief visit. I asked Pam about the female friend and Pam said that she is a “Chinese goddess” but American born and rasied from the Los Angeles area (Monterey Park to be exact). Bruce, I think that I am ready to test out eveything I have learned from you, the others and this site when I meet this Chinese goddess. So, wish me luck. Have you any advice for me?

  8. Bruce
    Bruce October 12, 2012 at 1:22 pm | | Reply

    Manny,

    Just try to know her and try to be her friend first. She was born here that doesn’t mean she’s wild etc etc!!! Remember she is raised in a traditional chinese family setting. Just expect her not to be wild. I know Monterey Park, Arcadia, temple city, pasendena, san marino, san gabriel, Rosemead and Alhambra areas etc. Now you have to call me a true ” sitfu” . hahahhahahhahahahha :). Be nice to her. Invite her over for family dinner and go to a movie. Tell your family to watch what they say in front of her. Some girls are very sensitive. I know you like Chinese women in a good way but just treat her like any types of women. Don’t look at her as a chinese goddess (woman). All I know is after you know a person for a while, you will only see her as a person you like/love. It has nothing to do with ethnicity ( race). Take things slow like you’re looking to find your future wife. A real relationship begins with friendship. Manny, if you’re looking for a one nightstand, my advice stops here :(. that’s why we have clubs and spring breaks ( cancun or daytona ,FL). CHinese/Asian women are very melod most of the time. They are very easy to talk to. Most don’t have a chip on their shoulders.

  9. Manny
    Manny October 12, 2012 at 2:46 pm | | Reply

    @Bruce, thanks for the advice. Excitement is already raging through my body and in my veins as I look forward to meeting this Chinese goddess. I will let you know of the results after this weekend, bro. Wish me luck. No, I am not looking for a one-night stand but a long term relationship.

  10. Manny
    Manny October 12, 2012 at 3:12 pm | | Reply

    Does anyone else have any advice for me in preparation for me to meet my Chinese goddess this weekend?

  11. Rebekah
    Rebekah October 12, 2012 at 3:30 pm | | Reply

    My boyfriend and I met on strange terms, and I actually never thought we would make it this far(6 years people!). I think in the first year of our relationship after he said I Love You the first time he didn’t say it again until almost a year and a half later! Now, even in the middle of a huge fight, he will remind me of how much he cares be it directly(ie: you know how much I love you) or indirectly(ie: I try to give you advice to make your life is easier). Sometimes it’s hard, and it is definitely different from my past relationships with non-Chinese men, but over time you learn all the ins and outs of how some Chinese men aren’t as forward with their affections, but how deeply their love runs. Aili, it’s only been 6 months, give it time and you will pick up on very subtle things that prove he loves you deeper than you know! 🙂

  12. dingjie
    dingjie October 12, 2012 at 4:50 pm | | Reply

    ..Yes Say I Love You
    Very simple
    But True I love you
    ………Very difficult
    You meet a good Chinese man

    It’s easy to say I love you

    may be a playboy

  13. askdsk
    askdsk October 12, 2012 at 9:54 pm | | Reply

    @Bruce
    What a load of crap.

  14. Bruce
    Bruce October 12, 2012 at 11:38 pm | | Reply

    @askdsk,

    Your advice to Manny?

  15. Blossom
    Blossom October 13, 2012 at 6:30 am | | Reply

    More than words, the strongest indication of love from any man, especially Chinese men, is going to be how much time they spend with you. Time = love. It really is that simple, albeit dissappointingly so! It is more efficient to just hear the words and be done with it! 🙂 Think back to how much time your lover devots to you and therein lies your answer. I agree jocelyn, with some examples and communication things can be a bit more open, but it isn’t necessary all the time. Maybe just when us females are feeling a bit fragile/PMS maybe? 🙂

  16. cvaguy
    cvaguy October 13, 2012 at 6:53 pm | | Reply

    @Blossom – I would qualify that as “how much available free time your lover devotes to”. We all have to make a living 🙂 Free time is choice time, that says a lot.
    @Manny – If you like her, you have to indicate so right off bat. “You are so cute!” etc. Be friend can be easily “Friend zoomed”. It is hard to change a friend into date, my expierence anyway. Love is chemistry not friendship. The dating process either enforces or diminishes the chemistry. My two cents.

  17. askdsk
    askdsk October 13, 2012 at 9:12 pm | | Reply

    We do need to use words. Mature women appreciate actions more than words. Walk the talk. But communicating thoughts and feelings make a person more alive. Being smarter in a relationship requires communication. Ask questions and tend to feelings, sometimes through meaningful words. I don’t think women always expect you to do something. Be a good listener and respond. That is an art itself. Physical affection should also be quite natural when you are attracted to someone.

    @ Manny
    I have no advice. The fact you try to put a stamp on all Chinese women disgusts me.

  18. Bruce
    Bruce October 14, 2012 at 9:27 am | | Reply

    In my opinion and experience, friend zone turned into relationships. Of course, if you’re looking for dates and not relationship , who cares about being friends. To me, I have to be able to talk to a woman as a friend first. I have a good friend just got married. He was her friend first and now they’re married. When you just soooooooo eager to get a gf , just talk , hug good bye, and kiss. easy as 1,2,3

    Btw, next morning call her back and say ” I had a fun evening out with you last night”. Don’t smother her with too much attention and maybe she’ll bite the bait. heheheheheh j/k lol
    Bruce 🙂

  19. Bruce
    Bruce October 15, 2012 at 8:28 pm | | Reply

    I think 110% here that I spend the most time with my wife. Seriously, you guys can’t beat me on this category. I express my feelings , ideas , opinions and complaints too much 24/7 . I can talk about any subjects. BRING IT ON!!

  20. Blossom
    Blossom October 16, 2012 at 5:04 am | | Reply

    You’re so funny Bruce! … A bright, happy spark on this forum! 🙂

  21. Bruce
    Bruce October 16, 2012 at 9:20 am | | Reply

    @Blossom,

    You love it huh? *winks*. You know I have a stressful job also so, I/we try to balance work, entertainment ,health and lifestyle all in one.

    Bruce 🙂

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

css.php
%d bloggers like this: